Ideal Navigation Model
Locations
- YMCA of Greater Richmond, Virginia
Focus Areas
- Economic Mobility
- Health
- Housing
“If our vision is to help more people thrive, then research is one of the most important tools we have. It helps us move beyond good intentions and toward a deeper understanding of what truly creates lasting change. The ultimate goal is not just to help people weather a crisis...it's to help them move from crisis, to stability, to thriving.”
The Issue
Many individuals and families across the country are facing multiple challenges at once, including housing instability, health needs, food insecurity, and financial stress. People experiencing financial or personal crises may have resources available to them but struggle to identify, access, and successfully navigate those services. Accessibility is key to getting resources in the hands of people who need them the most. When individuals seek out services, barriers such as internet connection and transportation can impact their ability to access key information to address their challenges. When they do gain access to resources, they often encounter a complex system with different programs and providers for each of their needs.
While comprehensive databases exist, individuals who use them require a certain level of independence for them to successfully navigate their problems and access services. This approach may cause those in need to miss out on possible beneficial resources, whether due to lack of digital literacy or reliable technology access.
Professional human navigators and interactive navigation platforms provide different levels of connection and support to people seeking services. There is a gap in research regarding the effectiveness of these methods to connect individuals with community resources and the long-term effect on individual outcomes, such as housing stability, food security, and employment.
The Intervention
YMCA of Greater Richmond works to ensure people and communities can thrive because everyone has opportunities to experience achievement, relationships, and belonging. Their economic mobility framework aims to move people along a pathway from crisis to stability to mobility.
YMCA recognizes different people may require different levels of assistance along that pathway. They offer two approaches to connecting people with community resources: Ideal Navigation Model and Help1RVA Self-Navigation.
The Ideal Navigation Model pairs clients with a navigator who provides structured, person-centered case-management. Navigators identify needs, connect clients with appropriate community organizations, assist with referrals and care coordination, and track their progress. The average navigation process lasts approximately 25 days.
Help1RVA Self-Navigation is an online platform for independent exploration of services. Participants enter their ZIP code, search available services, review eligibility requirements and provider information, and contact or submit referrals to providers themselves.
Both approaches share information on community resources with a difference in the level of navigation support.
Research Question
Among individuals in crisis, what is the impact of the YMCA’s Ideal Navigation Model, relative to the online Help1RVA Self-Navigation, on key outcomes such as financial stability, housing stability, and social determinants of health?
Intended Outcomes
Primary Outcomes
- Financial and economic health
- Housing stability
Secondary Outcomes
- Health
- Public benefits utilization
- Criminal justice interaction
Research Study Design
LEO will use a randomized controlled trial (RCT) to evaluate the impact of YMCA Greater Richmond’s Ideal Navigation Model and Help1RVA Self Navigation.
Individuals in the Greater Richmond area who seek assistance for social needs navigation are eligible to participate. The study focuses on new, non high-risk clients who complete an assistance request form themselves on the YMCA’s website.
Estimated enrollment over two years is 3,000 participants, with 2,000 participants assigned to work with a Navigator and 1,000 participants assigned to self-navigation on the website.
Randomization will allow the researchers to directly compare the two methods of service delivery.
The study will combine internal data for navigation activity and referral completion with external data from Experian, HMIS, SNAP and TANF (Virginia Department of Social Services), Virginia Criminal Sentencing Commission, address changes, and eviction filings.